problem in plotting cdf for gamma distribution

2 visualizaciones (últimos 30 días)
aboltabol
aboltabol el 10 de Mayo de 2018
Comentada: aboltabol el 11 de Mayo de 2018
Hello all I have a data series of size 16436x1. I have calculated the gamma CDF for the series using 'gamcdf' function. While plotting the result using plot('data','data_cdf) [data is the data series and data_cdf is the gamma CDF of the data], I am getting the plot (attached). I am confused as to why there are multiple lines in the graph? Please help I am attaching the files: data.mat, plot.pdf. data.mat contains two vectors: train(original data) and train_cdf(gamma CDF of the data)

Respuesta aceptada

John D'Errico
John D'Errico el 10 de Mayo de 2018
Editada: John D'Errico el 10 de Mayo de 2018
Is your data sorted in increasing order? (No, it is not.)
Plot draws a line from one point to the next. But you r data is not in increasing order. So what do you get? Lines all over the place, back and forth.
Just sort your data first.
help sort

Más respuestas (1)

Ameer Hamza
Ameer Hamza el 10 de Mayo de 2018
Editada: Ameer Hamza el 10 de Mayo de 2018
It appears that you evaluated the cdf functions for all the values in train. This is not necessary and also creating the problem in your case. Although you can use sort as suggested in @John's answer. But here is an alternate approach, which saves you from calculating and plotting a lot of points which are not even necessary. Although it seems that you estimated Gamma distribution parameters but for completeness here is the whole code,
param = gamfit(train);
param =
0.1306 8.2937 <-- These are estimated parameters of Gamma distribution
^ is k ^ is theta
x = 0:0.1:max(train); % you can plot to whtver value you want, i just used max(data)
cdf_values = gamcdf(x, param(1), param(2));
plot(x, cdf_values);
Also, in this case, you just need to calculate and plot few hundred points as compared 16436 points in your case, whereas the plot looks same.
  1 comentario
aboltabol
aboltabol el 11 de Mayo de 2018
Thanks Ameer. Actually, I am taking the gamma inverse in the next step to correct one series w.r.t to the gamma parameters of another, hence I have to take the whole series in the calculation. Thanks for your suggestion and help regarding the plotting issue.

Iniciar sesión para comentar.

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by