Problem 648. Cumulative probability of finding an unlikely combination
This is a supplemental problem to the CryptoMath problem. If you solve the problem methodically or randomly matters for expected solution time. This calculates the difference in techniques. My reference solution has some commented out graphics code to visualize the timing differences.
---
If you have N possible combinations to a lock you can calculate the likelihood of opening the lock as a percentage given X attempts.
There are two ways to figure out the combination to try:
- Try a random one, possibly trying an old one again
- Methodically doing them in order
Choosing a random combination is very fast and easy. No record keeping needed. Choosing a methodical way of trying them all is a little slower on each attempt, and incurs a fix cost before the first attempt is made.
If you have:
- Goal of G% cumulative probability of opening the lock
- Fixed cost of F seconds to start the methodical style
- TR seconds per random attempt
- TM seconds per methodical attempt
- N equally likely combinations
Which technique should you use to get to your goal chance fastest?
- 0 for random
- 1 for methodical
--- Note for the curious: The really short solution is gaming the system and just choosing randomly. Eventually one of the solutions will guess right on all the test suite.
Solution Stats
Problem Comments
-
2 Comments
bah, my lack of knowledge of probability fails me again
A very interesting probability problem applicable across a lot of areas underlies the solution. It isn't obvious at first glance. The solution is fairly short, but it takes a lot of thought to get it. I can't wait to see the length 14 solution!
Solution Comments
Show commentsProblem Recent Solvers32
Suggested Problems
-
Find all elements less than 0 or greater than 10 and replace them with NaN
15512 Solvers
-
16981 Solvers
-
3368 Solvers
-
Sum the numbers on the main diagonal
578 Solvers
-
Flip the vector from right to left
8866 Solvers
More from this Author51
Problem Tags
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!