Including external file is making workspace messy

3 visualizaciones (últimos 30 días)
atharva aalok
atharva aalok el 8 de Oct. de 2021
Comentada: Rik el 8 de Oct. de 2021
I have created a file named PLOT_STANDARDS.m put it in a folder and added that to path to include it in other files.
But when I include that file at the start of another script in the following manner:
%=================script begins here
clear; clc; close all;
% at the very beginning itself I include my file
PLOT_STANDARDS % this has lots of variables defined for easy access in any other script
%=============
% rest of the script goes here
My file PLOT_STANDARDS has a lot of variables which I have created to use as my defaults.
But including it in the above manner brings all those to the current workspace. This is very problematic as now I cannot find the variables of the current script easily. They get lost in the huge pile of variables that are imported from PLOT_STANDARDS.
I do not want to import specific variables from PLOT_STANDARDS instead I want to use any of the variable defined in there at will.
How to include PLOT_STANDARDS or access the variables in it in such a way that does not fill my workspace.
  3 comentarios
atharva aalok
atharva aalok el 8 de Oct. de 2021
I do not want to create a structure and save it and then include it in other files. as that would mean I will have to make sure to recompile the structure everytime I make changes to PLOT_STANDARDS.
Is there a way to include the file itself and somehow store its variables in a structure?
Rik
Rik el 8 de Oct. de 2021
You don't need to save your variables in a mat file, just store them in a struct. By having it be the output of your function you can even store it to a variable with a very short name. Typing s.var is not much more of a problem than typing var. Added bonus is that it is clear whether you are working with the loaded default or with a local copy.

Iniciar sesión para comentar.

Respuesta aceptada

Rik
Rik el 8 de Oct. de 2021
Let me expand on the suggestion of @Mathieu NOE:
  • Use functions, not scripts. Each function should have documentation explaining the purpose, inputs, and outputs. That way you don't have to worry about implementation details, which will also allow you to update code without worrying about whether the variables you're using might affect other scripts.
  • If you have a function that sets a lot of default values, let it return a struct. That way it is also clear where values come from.
  • You might want to consider changing your PLOT_STANDARDS to a class. That way you can import all default values the same way as a struct, but if you want to change settings you can have methods that check whether the new combination of settings is possible. In a way you can think of a class as a smart struct.
  • Don't use clear,clc,close all. It is an example of cargo cult programming and a code smell.
  3 comentarios
Stephen23
Stephen23 el 8 de Oct. de 2021
Editada: Stephen23 el 8 de Oct. de 2021
"In general why is it bad practice?"
Slow and uneccesary.
In almost all situations that beginners clear variables it is not required, but just slows down the code for no benefit. Using function workspaces is robust, repeatable, and ultimately a more efficient way to control the scope of variables.
Rik
Rik el 8 de Oct. de 2021
You can keep the workspace clean by using functions, and you can make sure you have a clean figure by creating one and using the handle in the rest of your function.
I also use these functions sometimes, but only during debugging will they ever appear at the top (which is also the only circumstance under which I will use a script instead of a function).

Iniciar sesión para comentar.

Más respuestas (0)

Categorías

Más información sobre Variables en Help Center y File Exchange.

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by