# Conditional Question Matlab Disagreement

1 visualización (últimos 30 días)
Jayden el 24 de Oct. de 2023
Comentada: Fabio Freschi el 24 de Oct. de 2023
(6+3)>8>2 - I said the answer would be zero but my teacher says it’s one and I’m super confused. Any explanation would be appreciated, thanks!
##### 0 comentariosMostrar -2 comentarios más antiguosOcultar -2 comentarios más antiguos

Iniciar sesión para comentar.

### Respuestas (3)

Stephen23 el 24 de Oct. de 2023
Editada: Stephen23 el 24 de Oct. de 2023
"...but my teacher says it’s one and I’m super confused. Any explanation would be appreciated, thanks!"
This code
(6+3)>8>2
ans = logical
0
is parsed from left-to-right and is equivalent to
((6+3)>8)>2
ans = logical
0
which comes down to either of these two cases (both of which return zero):
0>2
ans = logical
0
1>2
ans = logical
0
So even without adding 6+3 we know the result is always zero. In fact, the value of that sum is irrelevant.
Note that MATLAB has one operator >, it does not have a logical operator with three inputs that looks like A>B>C.
##### 4 comentariosMostrar 2 comentarios más antiguosOcultar 2 comentarios más antiguos
Stephen23 el 24 de Oct. de 2023
Editada: Stephen23 el 24 de Oct. de 2023
"I emailed my teacher and they said “ Work from right to left 8>2 ..."
The MATLAB documentation states "Within each precedence level, operators have equal precedence and are evaluated from left to right." An operator is only in one level, so repetitions of any operator will be parsed from left to right:
For what it is worth, left-to-right is generally a mathematical and computing convention:
Dyuman Joshi el 24 de Oct. de 2023
I am not sure which notation your teacher is using when saying to work from right to left for the given case in relation to MATLAB.
You should ask for an explaination.

Iniciar sesión para comentar.

Michael el 24 de Oct. de 2023
Editada: Michael el 24 de Oct. de 2023
I think you are right and your teacher is wrong.
MATLAB evaluates this expression from the left to the right (see chapter "Operator Precedence" in the MATLAB documentation) with respect to the parentheses. That means
• (6+3) = 9
• 9 > 8 = true (logical value 1)
• 1 > 2 = false (logical value 0)
Result of (6+3) > 8 > 2 = false (logical value 0)
##### 1 comentarioMostrar -1 comentarios más antiguosOcultar -1 comentarios más antiguos
John D'Errico el 24 de Oct. de 2023
And of course one can always verify that by a simple test.
(6+3) > 8 > 2
ans = logical
0
Trust, but verify.

Iniciar sesión para comentar.

Fabio Freschi el 24 de Oct. de 2023
I agree with all the comments and answers. But maybe one should read (6+3)>8>2 as "is 8 larger than 2 and lower than (6+3)?" that translates in
(6+3) > 8 && 8 > 2
ans = logical
1
##### 4 comentariosMostrar 2 comentarios más antiguosOcultar 2 comentarios más antiguos
Steven Lord el 24 de Oct. de 2023
FYI if you enter that expression in a file in MATLAB Editor, Code Analyzer will call out that it thinks that's what you intended to ask ("is 8 larger than 2 and lower than (6+3)?") and will display a Code Analyzer warning suggesting your alternative as a way to actually ask that question. I've attached a script file containing that expression:
dbtype example2037936.m
1 y = (6+3) > 8 > 2;
The codeIssues object will list the Code Analyzer messages for files or folders.
issues = codeIssues('example2037936.m');
Let's display the description of the only Code Analyzer message for that file, wrapped to 70 characters per line (so you can see the whole message without scrolling.)
string(textwrap(issues.Issues.Description, 70))
ans = 3×1 string array
"Expressions like a > b > c are interpreted as (a > b) > c. Typically, " "to test a > b > c mathematically, if all arguments are numeric " "scalars, use (a > b) && (b > c), otherwise use (a > b) & (b > c)."
Fabio Freschi el 24 de Oct. de 2023
Very interesting and useful comment: thank you @Steven Lord!
I guess I will never see that comment because a condition like that will never cross my mind!

Iniciar sesión para comentar.

### Categorías

Más información sobre Whos en Help Center y File Exchange.

### Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by