Getting NaN while using the ratio of power and factorial

4 views (last 30 days)
1
With the following piece of code, I get NaN
l=0;
lp=2;
d=200;
a2= ((-sqrt(d))^lp);
a3 =((-sqrt(d))^l);
sum1=0
for m=0:500
a1= ((2^m)*(d^m))/(factorial(m))
mul=a1*a2*a3;
sum1=sum1+mul;
end
Is there any way to modify the code to get rid of the issue?
  1 Comment
James Tursa
James Tursa on 13 Jul 2022
Cross posted on stackoverflow and answered there over 4 hours ago. If you had simply checked the answer there you could have saved yourself the trouble of posting here and getting essentially the same answer.

Sign in to comment.

Answers (4)

Torsten
Torsten on 13 Jul 2022
Edited: Torsten on 13 Jul 2022
exp(400)*200 is quite large ...
format long
l=0;
lp=2;
d=200;
a2= ((-sqrt(d))^lp);
a3 =((-sqrt(d))^l);
a1 = 1.0;
sum1 = a1;
for m=0:500
a1 = a1* 2*d/(m+1);
sum1=sum1+a1;
end
sum1 = sum1*a2*a3
sum1 =
1.044293406962028e+176
exp(400)*200
ans =
1.044293937952829e+176

Steven Lord
Steven Lord on 13 Jul 2022
m = 500;
d = 200;
The numerator and denominator of your expression (for sufficiently large m) both overflow to inf. Dividing infinity by infinity results in a NaN.
numerator = 2^m*d^m
numerator = Inf
denominator = factorial(m)
denominator = Inf
x = numerator / denominator
x = NaN
One potential approach to avoid this is to avoid explicitly computing 2^m, d^m, or factorial(m).
numeratorVector = repmat(2*d, 1, m); % prod(numeratorVector) would effectively give numerator
denominatorVector = 1:m; % prod(denominatorVector) would effectively give denominator
xVector = numeratorVector./denominatorVector;
format longg
x2 = prod(xVector)
x2 =
8.78187252741829e+166
Let's check symbolically.
numeratorSymbolic = sym(2*d)^m;
vpa(numeratorSymbolic) % Pretty big
ans = 
1.07150860718626732094842504906e+1301
denominatorSymbolic = factorial(sym(m));
vpa(denominatorSymbolic) % Also pretty big
ans = 
1.220136825991110068701238785423e+1134
x3 = vpa(numeratorSymbolic/denominatorSymbolic) % Big but not quite as big as above
x3 = 
8.7818725274182843596325298923868e+166
You could be a little more sophisticated / clever if you wanted (preemptively cancelling out factors of 2 in numeratorVector by dividing even values in denominatorVector by 2.) Or you could keep track of x for each value of m then figure out what you need to multiply it by to get x for the next value of m.

Benjamin Thompson
Benjamin Thompson on 13 Jul 2022
The factorial function output increases very fast as input increases. See "doc factorial" for details. The output is "inf" for input of 171 or larger.
  1 Comment
Steven Lord
Steven Lord on 13 Jul 2022
But 400^m overflows for m > 118 so this whole expression becomes infinite or undefined beyond that point.
d = 200;
(2*d)^118
ans = 1.1043e+307
(2*d)^119
ans = Inf

Sign in to comment.


Vijeta Singh Yadav
Vijeta Singh Yadav on 13 Jul 2022
Data overflow and underflow problem exists in the code
visit this link for avoid data overflow and underflow problems.

Tags

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by